Music while studying: what the research says, and why lo-fi is usually instrumental

Experiments and meta-analyses on background music agree on one thing: lyrics compete with reading. Here is what that means for study music.
Illustration: studying with music

Search for study music and you will find thousands of playlists promising better focus, better memory and better grades. The research on background music is far more cautious. It does not support grand promises, and in several experiments silence still comes out on top. But it does offer a few fairly consistent findings, and they matter a great deal for how you choose your study soundtrack. This guide summarises what the studies actually measure, what they have found, and how to turn that into sensible habits.

What the experiments actually measure

Most studies on this question follow the same pattern. Participants are given a task, usually reading a passage and answering comprehension questions, sometimes memorising a list of words or numbers, and their performance is compared across conditions: silence, instrumental music, music with lyrics, speech or noise. Results vary with the task, the music, the volume and the person, and the effects are generally small. That alone is a useful corrective. Background music is not a learning tool, and it rarely makes a dramatic difference either way.

It also helps to remember what these experiments leave out. They typically last minutes rather than hours, take place in quiet laboratories rather than shared flats or libraries, and assign music rather than letting people choose. Real studying involves long sessions, distractions, fatigue and the small daily struggle of getting started at all, and those are exactly the areas where music may play a different role.

The big picture: effects that cancel out

In 2011 Juliane Kämpfe, Peter Sedlmeier and Frank Renkewitz published a meta-analysis of studies on background music in adults. Taken as a whole, the effect was close to zero, but the authors argued that this overall null result hid opposing effects that cancelled each other out. Compared with no music, background music tended to disturb reading and had small detrimental effects on memory, while it had positive effects on emotional reactions and on sports performance. In other words, music can make us feel better and still make certain tasks a little harder.

The consistent finding: words compete with words

Where the evidence is clearest is lyrics. In a 2014 experiment published in Applied Cognitive Psychology, Nick Perham and Harriet Currie asked participants to complete reading comprehension tasks in four conditions: quiet, music with lyrics that they liked, music with lyrics that they disliked, and music without lyrics. Performance was best in quiet and with instrumental music, and worst with both kinds of lyrical music. Liking the songs made no difference: lyrical music the participants enjoyed was just as disruptive as lyrical music they disliked.

A larger picture comes from a 2018 Bayesian meta-analysis by Martin Vasilev, Julie Kirkby and Bernhard Angele, which pooled 65 studies on auditory distraction during reading. Background noise, speech and music all had a small but reliable detrimental effect on reading, and intelligible speech and music with lyrics caused the greatest distraction. The explanation most researchers favour is that language in the background competes for the same mental resources you need to process the language on the page.

Liked music is not automatically better

It seems intuitive that music you enjoy should help. The evidence is mixed. In another study, Perham and Martinne Sykora found that both liked and disliked music impaired the recall of lists compared with quiet, and that liked music was actually worse than disliked music. One plausible reading is that familiar, enjoyable music is simply more interesting, and so more likely to pull attention away from the task. Favourite songs may be excellent for mood, and still be the wrong choice for memorising vocabulary.

Tempo and volume matter too

Lyrics are not the only factor. In a 2012 experiment published in Psychology of Music, William Forde Thompson, Glenn Schellenberg and Adriana Letnic found that background music that was both fast and loud disrupted reading comprehension, while slower or quieter versions of the same music had much less effect. The practical lesson is simple: whatever you play should sit beneath the task, not compete with it.

What this means for lo-fi

This is the main reason study music is usually instrumental, and why jazz lo-fi has become such a common companion for reading and revision. It has no words to compete with the words on the page. Its tempo is moderate and steady, its dynamics are narrow, and its arrangements avoid sudden changes, so there is little to grab attention. It still carries mood, through warm chords and soft textures, which may make a long session feel more pleasant. None of this guarantees better results, but it does mean that lo-fi avoids the features the research most clearly links to distraction.

Practical guidelines

  • Avoid lyrics for verbal tasks. Reading, writing and memorising words are where lyrics interfere most. Save songs with vocals for breaks or for less demanding work.
  • Keep the volume low. Music should sit just above the room noise, not on top of your thoughts.
  • Prefer steady, predictable music. Sudden changes in tempo or loudness are more likely to pull your attention.
  • Be careful with favourites. Music you love and know by heart can be more distracting than something pleasant but unfamiliar.
  • Test it on yourself. Individual differences are large. Try the same kind of task with and without music for a few days and keep what works.

When silence wins

In several of these studies, silence still produced the best results. For the hardest material, such as a dense chapter, a new language or a demanding exam question, it may simply be the better option. Music can return for the easier parts of the session, for tasks such as tidying notes or drawing diagrams, or for the breaks in between. Choosing silence for the hardest twenty minutes of the evening is not a failure of discipline; it is a sensible use of what the evidence tells us.

A habit more than a hack

Where background music can genuinely help is in routine. Pressing play on the same instrumental stream every time you sit down can become a signal that a study session has started, which makes starting easier, and it can mask the unpredictable noises of a shared space. Pairing music with timed blocks of work, as we describe in focus sessions with lo-fi, makes that signal even clearer. These are modest benefits, but honest ones, and they are the spirit in which Mondolofi’s study music is made: quiet, wordless and there when you need it.

For specific tasks, see our guides to lo-fi for reading and lo-fi for writing and journaling. When you are ready to try, our study page collects the calmest, steadiest jazz lo-fi we publish.

Sources

  • Kämpfe, J., Sedlmeier, P. and Renkewitz, F. (2011), “The impact of background music on adult listeners: A meta-analysis”, Psychology of Music, 39(4), 424–448: doi.org/10.1177/0305735610376261
  • Perham, N. and Currie, H. (2014), “Does listening to preferred music improve reading comprehension performance?”, Applied Cognitive Psychology, 28(2), 279–284: doi.org/10.1002/acp.2994
  • Vasilev, M. R., Kirkby, J. A. and Angele, B. (2018), “Auditory distraction during reading: A Bayesian meta-analysis of a continuing controversy”, Perspectives on Psychological Science, 13(5), 567–597: doi.org/10.1177/1745691617747398
  • Perham, N. and Sykora, M. (2012), “Disliked music can be better for performance than liked music”, Applied Cognitive Psychology, 26(4), 550–555: pure.cardiffmet.ac.uk
  • Thompson, W. F., Schellenberg, E. G. and Letnic, A. K. (2012), “Fast and loud background music disrupts reading comprehension”, Psychology of Music, 40(6), 700–708: doi.org/10.1177/0305735611400173

Journal

Keep reading

All articles →